Spring 2024 Classes in the History of Philosophy at ND

Outline

Graduate Classes

PHIL 83206: Towards a history of psychology: Ancient and medieval therapies of the soul

Wiebke Marie Stock | MW 11:00am-12:15pm

In ancient and medieval texts the soul is the principle of life, of sense-perception, emotions, passions, rational thought and ethical behavior. Throughout history, the investigation of the soul has been special in two ways. First of all, we are not addressing an external topic; we are treating ourselves. Secondly, this study of ourselves is not merely meant to describe and analyze, but to change and to form. Ancient philosophers thought of their work as "care of the soul". The soul is not a mechanism or machine, but something living which can err and go wrong. Pre-modern authorities often described this in the terms of sickness: The body may be sick and need the help of the doctor, and the soul may need therapy if it is sick. In the course, we will address a selection of texts and topics from ancient and medieval sources (Plato, Aristotle, Galen, the Stoics, Neoplatonic authors and Christian authors from late Antiquity and the Middle Ages), and compare them with select contemporary texts. What constitutes a healthy soul? What are the sicknesses of the soul? What therapies are recommended? How can one build resilience and how much resilience is right? What role does gender play? The course will also integrate lectures/discussions with practicing therapists and a field trip to "mindworks" (Chicago Museum of cognitive psychology).

Crosslisted With: MI 33022, HHS 33022, CLAS 33022, STV 33022

PHIL 93238: Avicenna, Averroes, and Aquinas on the Intellect

Therese Cory & Stephen Ogden | T 3:30pm-6:15pm

An in-depth investigation into three competing medieval theories of intellect, from Avicenna (Ibn Sina), Averroes (Ibn Rushd), and Thomas Aquinas. These are three of the most important medieval noetic systems, which adapt Aristotelian and Neo-Platonic views within the Islamic and Christian traditions and which shape influential debates into later medieval and Renaissance philosophy. Readings include Avicenna's Psychology of The Cure; Averroes' Long Commentary on De Anima; Aquinas's De Unitate Intellectus; and important secondary scholarship.

Crosslisted With: MI 93366, HPS 93238

PHIL 83611: Democracy & Virtue

Vincent Munoz & Dave O'Connor | MW 11:00am-12:15pm

“Democracy & Virtue?” investigates a simple question: Does democracy foster virtue? The class will approach this question, first, through a philosophical investigation of the nature of political regimes, including democratic regimes. This investigation will take place via a careful reading of and discussions about Plato’s Republic. The class will then turn to an examination of America as a modern constitutional democracy. Our primary text for this part of class will be Tocqueville’s Democracy in America. Additional readings from Montesquieu, The Federalist, and Catholic writers will also be introduced. Students should expect to read carefully and deliberately and to participate extensively in class, which will be conducted as a seminar conversation.

Crosslisted With: CNST 30619, POLS 30700, PHIL 43400

PHIL 93606: Philosophy of Edith Stein

Kristopher McDaniel | Th 12:30pm-3:15pm

This course will focus on some of the central texts of the philosophy of Edith Stein. Edith Stein was an important member of the phenomenological movement: she was Husserl's first assistant (Heidegger followed after) and wrote important works in this tradition. She was also a scholar of scholastic philosophy. One of her last works is a treatise on systematic metaphysics that integrates insights from phenomenology, neo-Kantianism, and scholastic metaphysics. We’ll begin by discussing the general philosophical and contextual background to Edith Stein's early works. We’ll then discuss several of her works, ranging from her first book The Problem of Empathy up to Finite and Eternal Being. We will largely focus on her views about philosophical methodology, phenomenology, epistemology, philosophy of mind, and metaphysics, though we will also touch on her ethics and philosophy of religion.

PHIL 93812: History of Philosophy of Science from the Scientific Revolution to 1900

Don Howard | TTh 11:00am-12:15pm

This course examines the work of key figures from the history of natural philosophy and science. Placing the philosophical work of Leibniz, Newton, Hume, Kant, Alexander Humboldt, Whewell, J. S. Mill, Helmholtz, Ernst Mach, Wilhelm Wundt, William James, Einstein, Henri Poincare, Bergson, and others, within a wider philosophical, historical, and cultural context, we will explore how and why they identified their central problems and the methods they used to approach those. We will focus on understanding how the central problems and theories that these figures worked on, ranging from questions of space, time, motion and substance/matter to theories of human sensibility and perception, to wider epistemological and metaphysical investigations, engaged the scholarly communities surrounding them, and helped them promote broader programmatic goals for reshaping and reforming philosophy/science. As they engaged contemporary philosophers/scientists over fundamental philosophical questions, they pressed new ideals of knowledge and programs to reform natural philosophy and reorganize the broader scholarly community - and society itself (e.g., Kant). We will explore how these natural philosophers framed new epistemologies and simultaneously promoted new ideals of the philosopher, scholar, and/or educated citizen, who would be capable of creating valid knowledge. In sum, we will explore how preeminent natural philosophers, at once, made original contributions to epistemology, understanding of space and time, and metaphysics, as they framed new visions of the knowing subject within a changing society.

Crosslisted With: HPS 93812

MI 60801: Augustine's Confessions

Hildegund Müller | TTh 12:30pm-1:45pm

A reading of Augustine’s Confessions, partly in Latin and in its entirety in English, with a special emphasis on close reading and precise grammatical and stylistic analysis. We will focus on understanding Confessions as a work of Latin literature and Christian philosophy, part of the great late ancient endeavor to develop new genres and styles to mirror the new belief system, yet connected to the classical world in multiple ways. In addition to the narrative itself, Augustine’s personal experience, Confessions allows the reader to gain insight into his major philosophical tenets and the conversations and controversies of his life. We will also discuss important scholarly questions (origin, historical setting, sources and parallels, biblical framework, structure, philosophical background, modern readings, etc.) and read selections of scholarly literature.

Crosslisted With: CLLA 40054, CLLA 60054,  MI 40801

MI 80367: Elements of Reasoning in Neoplatonism: Metaphysics and Nature

Denis Robichaud | TTh 9:30am-10:45am

A distinctive feature of premodern philosophy and science is the organization of nature, reasoning, and methods into elements. Philosophers, scientists, and mathematicians in the premodern world conceived of elements of reasoning as they developed axiomatic methods of demonstration and argumentation. Perhaps the most famous example of this kind of reasoning is Euclid’s Elements, but other ancient and medieval philosophers composed works in elemental modes and formulated axiomatic methods (sometimes known as demonstrating in more geometrico or a geometrical way) to study metaphysics and nature. Proclus’s Elements of Theology are a foundational and paradigmatic text in this tradition (and to a lesser extent so too is his shorter Elements of Physics). This course is centered on a close examination of Proclus’s Elements of Theology but will also study selections in this premodern tradition, including Porphyry’s Sententiae, and Cusanus’s De non aliud, as well as Boethius’s De Hebdomadibus and the Liber de causis, along with their respective commentaries by Thomas Aquinas. No prerequisites are required for the course, but familiarity with ancient and medieval philosophy would be useful. Students will be invited to read texts in translations and in their original language. No knowledge of ancient languages (Greek and Latin) is required nor of other modern languages (e.g., Italian, French, German) but some linguistic training in these languages would be beneficial.

Crosslisted With: HPS 80146

THEO 60713: Modern Jewish Theology

Isaac Slater | MW 3:30pm-4:45pm

Abraham Heschel’s assertion that “no religion is an island” is especially true of modern Judaism. From Moses Mendelssohn’s defense of religious freedom to Heschel’s support of the civil rights movement, modern Jewish theology is characterized by an ongoing dialogue with other faith traditions, especially Christianity. This course explores the diverse manifestations of modern Jewish theology and its dialogical contextualizations from the eighteenth century to the present. We will read and analyze seminal works by Heschel, Mendelsohn, Martin Buber, Franz Rosenzweig, Margarete Susman, and Emmanuel Levinas, among others. In each case, we will analyze their reliance on diverse ancient, medieval, and modern traditions. Topics to be discussed include the theology of praxis, modern messianism and mysticism, political theology, theological ethics, theories of religious language, and Jewish existentialism. In addition to providing access to texts and ideas that continue to shape contemporary Judaism, the arc of the course invites reflective wrestling with its core definitions: What should we consider modern in the context of Jewish thought? What speculation amounts to a system we can call theology? Does modern interreligious dialogue blur the boundary between Christian and Jewish theology? And if so, what makes certain ideas Jewish?

Crosslisted With: THEO 40729

THEO 83214: From Luther to Scheler

Ulrich Lehner | MW 11:00am-12:15pm

This seminar aims to introduce students to various discourses that have influenced modern theology. We will cover topics such as how to interpret texts, assess them, and understand the context and assumptions within them. The seminar title may seem confusing since it connects an Augustinian friar and a Cologne philosopher. However, they both recognize the importance of the emotional, intuitive, and a-logical aspects of humanity and reflect on inner life. We will discuss devotio moderna and its influences, Erasmus, the Augustinian reform movement under Staupitz, and Luther himself. The second area we will explore is the theology developed after the Reformation. We will discuss approaches to Scripture and Revelation, changes in the understanding of faith, and how theologians analyze and prepare for faith. The third area of inquiry will focus on the question of certitude in matters of faith. We will examine how theologians negotiate ambiguity and manage certitude. We will also discuss the theological notes and how they assign levels of authority to church teachings. Fourth, we will explore the developments that led to the creation of the Enlightenment and what it was. We will cover Enlightenment thought and how it influenced the recovery of intuition in Schleiermacher, Dilthey, and Scheler. Lastly, we will examine how to deal with accounts of miracles or the impossible such as bilocations or levitations. While I have not yet determined the entire syllabus, I am considering using selections from various books, eg.: Van Engen, Sisters and Brothers of the Common Life; Luther, Rejection of monastic vows; Erasmus, Enchiridion; A. Arnaud, The Necessity of Faith in Jesus Christ; Tutino, Credulitas; C. Eire, They Flew; H. Plessner, Limits of Community; Henry Holden, Analysis of Faith; M. Scheler, Of the Eternal in Man; M. Scheler, Resentment; The idols of self-knowledge; Dilthey, Introduction to the Human Sciences; Schleiermacher, Reden; R. Otto, The Holy; Chadwick, From Bossuet to Newman; M. Hunter, The Decline of Magic; Kripal, Superhumanities.

Crosslisted With: HIST 83501

THEO 83265: Augustine's de Trinitate

John Cavadini | F 9:00am-11:45am

The course explores Augustine as a theologian, with particular attention given to Augustine's De Trinitate.

HIST 83110: Genealogies of Islamic Thought: Counterpoints in the History of Ideas

The course examines key writings in the history of Islamic thought. Using a variety of theoretical approaches ranging from writings by Ibn Khaldun, Marshall Hodgson to Michel Foucault, this advanced course examines the conditions under which multiplicities of Islamic knowledge, discourses and domains of power had been formulated over time. The course will utilize Hodgson's The Venture of Islam and Ibn Khaldun's, Muqaddima as the two main texts. Several other readings authored by scholars ranging from Iqbal, Fazlur Rahman, Jabri, Laroui in addition to theorists like Collingwood, Koselleck and Asad will be studied. The goal of the course is to engage in a textured and fine grain reading of how Muslim domains of knowledge and ideas were formulated over time.

 Crosslisted With: IIPS 73202

Undergraduate Classes

PHIL 20414: Introduction to Marx

Gabriel Day | MW 3:30pm-4:45pm

In this course, we will examine the philosophical ideas of Karl Marx, including his views on work, human nature, and freedom. We will focus on reading primary texts, from Marx's early manuscripts to excerpts from Capital. Additional readings will include philosophical responses to Marx's ideas from other thinkers.

PHIL 20804: Descartes and Pascal: Early Modern French Philosophy before 1700

John Waldrop | MW 2:00pm-3:15pm

The primary goal of the course is to introduce students to some of the central thinkers and historical controversies animating the French intellectual scene between the Reformation and the height of the enlightenment in the eighteenth century. Central authors include Montaigne, Descartes, and Pascal; topics to be addressed include skepticism, natural philosophy, and rationalism, and the relationship of these to questions of morals, culture, and religious belief, including divine grace and the role of religious institutions.

Crosslisted With: PRL 20804

PHIL 20816: The Death of God: Atheism in Modern European Culture and Thought

Robert Norton | TTh 12:30pm-1:45pm

Over the last decade or so, there has been a new and prominent wave of "New Atheism," often promoted in popular books that reach a wide and, apparently, appreciative audience. Yet, atheism is as old as religion itself, and in the Western tradition has roots that extend into the earliest recorded history. In this class we will consider atheism on its own merits - its arguments, values, and intentions - but also as a historical phenomenon, tracing its original expressions and especially its rise during the "modern" period beginning in the 17th and 18th centuries. We will thus focus on Spinoza, Hume, d'Holback, Ludwig Feuerbach, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and among the "New Atheists" Daniel Dennett, Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, and Christopher Hitchens.

Crosslisted With: GE 23620

PHIL 30301: Ancient and Medieval Philosophy

David Cory | MW 9:30am-10:45am

This course will concentrate on major figures and persistent themes. A balance will be sought between scope and depth, the latter ensured by a close reading of selected texts.

PHIL 30302: History of Modern Philosophy

Alix Cohen | TTh 2:00pm-3:15pm

This course examines the sweeping transformations of philosophy in the 17th and 18th centuries by exploring some of the leading philosophers of that era. Topics include innovations in metaphysics, epistemology, philosophy of mind, philosophical theology, and the natural sciences, many of which continue to shape the agenda in contemporary philosophy.

PHIL 43205: Joint Seminar in Philosophy and Theology: Simone Weil and Edith Stein

Ann Astell & Jordan Rodgers | WF 3:30pm-4:45pm

This course pairs two extraordinary Jewish women philosophers of the World War II period who died during the period of Nazi persecution—Stein (1891-1942) in Auschwitz, and Weil (1901-1943) in England. Both studied under (and with) noted male philosophers—Husserl, Heidegger, Scheler, Von Hildebrand, and Alain, among others—and they developed their original insights on empathy and education (Stein), decreation and affliction (Weil) partly in response to their teachers. Both women struggled with their Jewish identity—Weil exemplifying an unconventional Christian Platonism and mysticism, Stein becoming a Catholic nun and canonized saint. Both wrote autobiographies. Literary and artistic criticism, meditations on mystical writings and experiences, and creative expressions (poetry and plays), as well as important essays on politics, philosophy, and theology belong to their fertile writings. Their lives and letters have inspired, in turn, the creative expressions of others: novels, plays, and poetry. Their intellectual quests in the shadow of the Holocaust led them to take up theological questions, studying St. Thomas Aquinas, Dionysius the Areopagite, St. John of the Cross (Stein), St. Francis, Bernanos, Marx, Plato, and Pascal (Weil). The answers they gave to God and others testify to the heroism and brilliance of their spiritual searches for truth and help to explain their continuing influence within the Church.

Crosslisted with: THEO 43205

PHIL 30409: American Political Thought

Paul Weithman | MW 2:00pm-2:50pm

Coming to grips with American political thought is at once an historical and a philosophical task. Students in this course will take on that task under the guidance of one faculty member from the Department of History and one from the Department of Philosophy. The guiding questions of the course are: How have ideas about freedom, equality and the social contract played out in the history of American political thought? When have we realized those ideas and when have we failed? Do those ideas provide us adequate guidance? The exploration of American political thought will be divided into six periods: The Founding, the Civil War era, the late 19th-century, the New Deal to the 1960s, the 1960s to the 1990s, and the 1990s to the present. The course has no prerequisites, though students wishing to count it toward the Philosophy requirement must previously have taken "Introduction to Philosophy."

PHIL 43400: Democracy & Virtue

Vincent Munoz & Dave O'Connor | MW 11:00am-12:15pm

“Democracy & Virtue?” investigates a simple question: Does democracy foster virtue? The class will approach this question, first, through a philosophical investigation of the nature of political regimes, including democratic regimes. This investigation will take place via a careful reading of and discussions about Plato’s Republic. The class will then turn to an examination of America as a modern constitutional democracy. Our primary text for this part of class will be Tocqueville’s Democracy in America. Additional readings from Montesquieu, The Federalist, and Catholic writers will also be introduced. Students should expect to read carefully and deliberately and to participate extensively in class, which will be conducted as a seminar conversation.

Crosslisted With: CNST 30619, POLS 30700, PHIL 83611

PHIL 43605: Pragmatism

Curtis Franks | TTh 2:00pm-3:15pm

This upper division course will be an introduction to American Pragmatism ranging over the classical texts of Pierce, James and Dewey to the contemporary texts of Putnam and Rorty.

MI 40801: Augustine's Confessions

Hildegund Müller | TTh 12:30pm-1:45pm

A reading of Augustine’s Confessions, partly in Latin and in its entirety in English, with a special emphasis on close reading and precise grammatical and stylistic analysis. We will focus on understanding Confessions as a work of Latin literature and Christian philosophy, part of the great late ancient endeavor to develop new genres and styles to mirror the new belief system, yet connected to the classical world in multiple ways. In addition to the narrative itself, Augustine’s personal experience, Confessions allows the reader to gain insight into his major philosophical tenets and the conversations and controversies of his life. We will also discuss important scholarly questions (origin, historical setting, sources and parallels, biblical framework, structure, philosophical background, modern readings, etc.) and read selections of scholarly literature.

 Crosslisted With: CLLA 40054, CLLA 60054, MI 60801

THEO 20258: Aquinas, Faith, and Wisdom

Matthew Messer | MWF 2:00pm-2:50pm

Thomas Aquinas is one of the foremost theologians and teachers in the Christian tradition. This course offers a theological introduction to the teachings of the Christian faith through Aquinas's writings, covering his principal claims about God, Christ, human beings, and the Church and sacraments. This topical exploration will highlight the interconnectedness of various doctrines and the systematic quality of Aquinas's own teaching, allowing us to engage with the presentation of a coherent Christian worldview. At the same time, the course emphasizes the dynamic relation between these theological topics as reflected in the structure of the Summa theologiae: God as the beginning and end of all creatures; human beings as made to find their fulfillment in God; and Christ the incarnate God as the way of return, mediated through his sacraments and Church. The course approaches these doctrines under the integrative concept "wisdom," following Aquinas's understanding of the theologian's task as one of growing in the wisdom of God. This task, which puts reason at the service of faith, constitutes an intellectual response to the divine calling of human beings to participate in the supernatural life.

PLS 13186: Literature University Seminar: Reading the Enlightenment: Shakespeare to Goethe

Christopher Chowrimootoo | MW 2:00pm-3:15pm

The Enlightenment (roughly the 17th - 18th centuries) has been celebrated as the birth of the modern world, the dawning of an age of reason that cast off the dogmatism and superstition of the past. Yet it has also been castigated for its hubris, prejudice, and narrow-minded rationalism. In this course, you will have the opportunity to examine the foundations of modern European thought for yourself by reading, analyzing, and discussing some of the Enlightenment's greatest texts. Authors include William Shakespeare, Francis Bacon, René Descartes, Thomas Hobbes, Blaise Pascal, Jonathan Swift, David Hume, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Voltaire, Adam Smith, Immanuel Kant, Thomas Malthus, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Jane Austen, and Johann von Goethe. Under the direction of a seminar leader, students study and discuss a range of major texts from the period of the Enlightenment, chosen on the basis of their enduring value and considerable influence on the subsequent Western Tradition. Through the reading of selected "Great Books", students will acquire a broad intellectual background while developing their abilities to read texts critically, formulate articulate and thoughtful arguments, and communicate effectively.

PLS 20412: Fundamental Concepts of Natural Science

Robert Goulding | MW 11:00am-12:15pm

This course raises questions fundamental to our experience of the physical world. Questions such as "What is space?" and "What is time?" and broader issues about the nature of life are initially raised through a close reading of Plato's Timaeus and Aristotle's Physics, along with excerpts from other ancient texts. In attempting to answer these questions over the course of the semester, we will read a wide variety of sources: principally ancient and modern primary texts, with some secondary readings. These readings will include Euclid's Elements, Descartes' Principles of Philosophy, and Einstein's Theories of Relativity.

PLS 30302: Political and Constitutional Theory: Ancient and Modern

Emma Planinc

An approach to understanding the fundamental problems of political community and the nature of various solutions, especially that of democracy. Readings will include, but are not limited to, Aristotle's Politics, Locke's Second Treatise, and selections from The Federalist Papers and American founding documents.

PLS 40302: Metaphysics and Epistemology

Felicitas Munzel

 

An engagement with philosophical conceptions of the nature of knowledge, reality, and the relation between them. Selections from the Platonic tradition, Aristotle's Metaphysics, and Kant's Critique of Pure Reason form the basis of the course. Other readings may include works by such thinkers as Aquinas, Heidegger, and other 20th Century authors.